Cam’s Pizzeria – Penn Yan

At 25 Main Street in Penn Yan's historic district, Cam's Pizzeria is the kind of neighborhood pizza shop that small-town New York does better than anywhere else on earth. The operation is straightforward — New York-style pies, calzones, strombolis, wings, subs, and salads — but the execution has earned Cam's a staggering collection of FLX […]

Blush

Blush has been a quiet force on Fall Street in Seneca Falls for years, earning Silver for Best Women's Clothing Store three years running (2023, 2024, 2025) along with Silver for Best Boutique in both 2023 and 2022. That kind of sustained recognition — never flashy, always present — is the profile of a shop […]

Big Oak Golf Course

Tucked along Packwood Road on the outskirts of Geneva, Big Oak Golf Course has been the Finger Lakes' most decorated public course for years running — Gold for Best Golf Course in 2022, 2023, and 2024, with a Silver in 2025. That three-year Gold streak is not something you fluke your way into. The 18-hole […]

Bella’s Seneca Lake Steakhouse

Bella's sits on Routes 5 & 20 between Geneva and Waterloo, and it does one thing extremely well: steak. Three consecutive FLX Finest Gold awards for Best Steakhouse (2022, 2023, 2024) is the kind of streak that does not happen by accident. The menu is built around prime cuts — thick, well-seasoned, charred to order […]

Bass Pro Shops

Bass Pro Shops needs no introduction as a national brand, but its presence in the FLX Finest awards speaks to something specific about the Finger Lakes outdoor culture: when locals need serious gear for serious pursuits, they still gravitate toward the big box with the taxidermy. The Auburn-area store earned Silver for Best Outdoors/Camping Store […]

Barrett Marine

If there is a single name that dominates the Finger Lakes boating scene, it is Barrett Marine. Operating from West River Road in Waterloo — strategically positioned between Seneca and Cayuga Lakes — this family-run operation has swept the FLX Finest awards so thoroughly that the competition barely registers. Gold for Best Marina, Best Boat […]

Bagels & Cakes

Every college town and lake town needs a great bagel shop, and Bagels & Cakes is Geneva's. Operating out of a no-frills storefront at 476 Hamilton Street, this place has won back-to-back FLX Finest Gold for Best Bagels in 2024 and 2025, and if you have ever wondered whether a small-town bagel shop can compete […]

Bad Burro Coffee Company

On the Waterloo-Geneva Road, where the commute between Seneca and Cayuga lake country runs through flat farmland and not much else, Bad Burro Coffee Company has become a genuinely essential pit stop. The concept is simple and ruthlessly efficient: a double drive-thru that keeps the line moving while the baristas inside crank out an enormous […]

Ashley Lynn Winery

Ashley Lynn is not your typical Finger Lakes tasting room. There are no slate-gray walls, no sommeliers swirling Riesling, and no tasting fees. This is a family-run winery on Route 318 in Waterloo — half a mile from the Finger Lakes Premium Outlets — where the Hurlbut family has been farming apples on 130 acres […]

Ardin Kay Boutique

In a town where the main drag doubles as a wine trail pit stop, Ardin Kay Boutique has become the reason people actually get out of the car and walk Penn Yan's Main Street. Tucked into a storefront at 112 Main, this women's clothing shop has built a following that goes well beyond Yates County […]