On Route 364 outside Penn Yan, in a stretch of countryside shaped by Mennonite farming traditions and rolling vineyard hills, Sugar Creek Foods fills a gap that no chain grocery or drugstore covers. This is a proper health food store — organic produce, bulk dry goods, natural supplements, specialty flours, and the kinds of pantry staples that people who care about ingredient labels actually want to buy. The selection reflects the community it serves: practical, honest, and unpretentious.

For Finger Lakes visitors, Sugar Creek is worth knowing about if you're renting a lakehouse near Keuka and want to stock the kitchen with something better than what the nearest Stewart's offers. The bulk section alone justifies a stop — grains, nuts, dried fruits, and baking supplies sold by weight, the way your grandmother used to shop. It's small, it's no-frills, and it won't show up in glossy travel magazines, but it's exactly the kind of locally-rooted store that makes a region feel lived-in rather than just visited. Fair prices, quality ingredients, and the kind of quiet reliability that earns an FLX Finest nod from people who shop there every week.