Sitting right on Lakefront Drive in Geneva, Long Pier Ice Cream & Rentals holds one of the most enviable locations in the Finger Lakes: steps from Seneca Lake, directly on the waterfront path that connects the town pier to the state park. Founded in 2005 by the Mirras family, it has grown from a seasonal lakeside stand into what is arguably the most decorated ice cream operation in the region. The numbers speak for themselves: Gold for Best Ice Cream every year from 2022 through 2024, Gold for Best Dessert from 2023 through 2025, and Silver for Best Ice Cream in 2025. Seven awards across four years from the same voter pool. That kind of run does not happen without something genuinely special in the freezer case.

The menu goes well beyond the standard scoop shop playbook. Long Pier serves premium hard ice cream and frozen custard alongside more adventurous options, including wine-flavored ice cream that nods to the Seneca Lake wine trail just down the road. The frozen custard is rich and dense in the best possible way, and seasonal flavors rotate often enough to keep regulars guessing. They also serve Zweigle's hot dogs, Rochester's beloved contribution to the American hot dog canon, which makes Long Pier a legitimate lunch destination and not just a dessert detour.

The waterfront setting is a huge part of the appeal. Grabbing a cone and walking out to the pier while the sun drops over Seneca Lake is one of Geneva's simplest and best summer experiences. Long Pier is a family operation that has gotten better every year, and the FLX Finest voters have noticed every step of the way.