At 25 Main Street in Penn Yan's historic district, Cam's Pizzeria is the kind of neighborhood pizza shop that small-town New York does better than anywhere else on earth. The operation is straightforward — New York-style pies, calzones, strombolis, wings, subs, and salads — but the execution has earned Cam's a staggering collection of FLX Finest awards across multiple categories. Gold for Best Pizza in 2024, Gold for Best Appetizers in 2025, Silver nods for salad and cheap eats — this is a place that locals vote for year after year, in category after category, because the whole menu works.

The pizza is the anchor. Cam's does proper New York-style — hand-tossed, foldable, with that slightly charred undercarriage that separates a good slice from a forgettable one. But the appetizers deserve equal attention, and the Gold in that category for 2025 suggests the kitchen takes its starters as seriously as its pies. The salads are legitimately good too, which is not something you expect to say about a pizza joint, but the consecutive Silver awards for Best Salad across multiple years speak for themselves. Add in pickup and delivery options, and you have a place that covers every base.

Cam's is not trying to reinvent pizza or impress food critics with truffle oil and burrata. It is doing the fundamentals with care and consistency, at prices that make it one of the best values in the Finger Lakes. For a quick dinner, a late-night order, or feeding a crowd after a day on Keuka Lake, Cam's is the default choice in Penn Yan — and has been for a while.