In Naples — the charming village tucked into the southern end of Canandaigua Lake, famous for its grape festival and dramatic fall foliage — Rennoldson's Market at 136 South Main Street is the grocery store that keeps the community fed. The 2024 Gold for Best Grocery Store recognizes a family-owned market that stocks everything from fresh produce and artisan goods to everyday necessities, all in a space small enough that the staff knows your name after a few visits. Naples is not a town that supports a chain supermarket, which makes Rennoldson's not just a convenience but a necessity — and a beloved one.

The market's strength is its curation. Rather than trying to compete on volume with the big-box stores in Canandaigua or Geneva, Rennoldson's focuses on quality and local sourcing. The produce reflects what regional farms are growing, the meat case is stocked with care, and the selection of artisan and specialty items gives the store a character that generic groceries lack. For visitors staying in the Naples area — whether for the wine and spirits scene, the Bristol Mountain ski crowd, or the hikers exploring the gorges — Rennoldson's is where you provision for the week. It is the kind of market that makes you wish your hometown had an equivalent.