At 1963 Highway 20 in Waterloo, LC New York occupies a spot in the consignment landscape that leans more curated boutique than secondhand shop. The 2024 Silver for Best Consignment/Thrift Store at FLX Finest reflects a model that prioritizes selectivity over volume — you will not find racks crammed with everything that came through the door. Instead, the inventory is edited with an eye toward quality, current style, and condition, which means the shopping experience feels closer to retail than rummage.

The Highway 20 corridor between Geneva and Seneca Falls has become an increasingly interesting stretch for independent retail, and LC New York contributes to that momentum with a mix of clothing, accessories, and home goods that appeal to shoppers who want value without sacrificing taste. The consignment model works particularly well in the Finger Lakes, where the population is style-conscious enough to produce quality consignment inventory but price-conscious enough to appreciate the savings. LC New York bridges those two realities effectively.

For visitors passing through the Waterloo area — whether headed to Seneca Falls, the outlet malls in Waterloo, or the wine trails beyond — LC New York is the kind of stop that rewards a quick detour. The prices are fair, the selection is current, and the turnover is fast enough that repeat visits feel worthwhile. In a consignment category that has gotten increasingly competitive in the FLX Finest voting, earning Silver speaks to a level of customer loyalty that only comes from consistently delivering finds worth finding.